+44 (0) 121 582 0192 [email protected]


In the intricate and highly regulated realm of healthcare, data privacy is not just a compliance requirement but a cornerstone of patient trust and safety. Healthcare practices across the globe, especially in the United States, are obligated to navigate a labyrinth of local, state, and international data protection laws. This article delves into how US healthcare practices can establish a data privacy framework that harmonises with various legislations, including HIPAA, HITECH Act, 21st Century Cures Act, GDPR, CCPA, U.S. state laws, HITRUST CSF, Information Blocking Rule, and the Interoperability and Patient Access Final Rule.


HIPAA: The Bedrock of Patient Data Security

Enacted in 1996, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) is pivotal in the U.S. for ensuring the confidentiality and security of patient health information. It requires healthcare entities and their associates to implement rigorous safeguards and promptly notify individuals of any breaches. HIPAA’s stringent standards form the foundation of any healthcare data privacy framework.


HITECH Act: Reinforcing HIPAA

The HITECH Act of 2009 fortifies HIPAA by intensifying penalties for data breaches and advocating for the adoption of Electronic Health Records (EHRs). It underscores the significance of secure electronic health information exchange, thereby amplifying patient data protection.


21st Century Cures Act: Fostering Innovation and Privacy

The 21st Century Cures Act of 2016 is a paradigm shift focusing on promoting scientific innovation while enhancing data sharing and privacy for patients. This act plays a critical role in alleviating administrative burdens and improving healthcare delivery.


GDPR: A Global Impact on Data Protection

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), effective from 2018 in the EU, also affects U.S. healthcare entities dealing with European patients. It demands strict data protection measures, including for health data, and necessitates informed consent for data processing, with severe penalties for non-compliance. US healthcare practices offering services to EU and UK citizens where they have no legal entity in UK or EU are obligated to appoint a UK / EU representative according to Article 27 of the UK and EU GDPR regulations.


CCPA and State-Specific Laws: Localised Data Rights

The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) (CPRA) of 2020, along with privacy laws in states like Virginia, Colorado, Connecticut, Utah, and others, provide residents with significant control over their personal data, including health information. These laws mandate businesses to be transparent about data practices and allow individuals to request data deletion or access to their data..


HITRUST CSF: A Unified Compliance Framework

The Health Information Trust Alliance Common Security Framework (HITRUST) isn’t a regulation but a robust framework that aligns healthcare organisations with various security and privacy standards. It offers a comprehensive strategy for protecting patient data across diverse regulatory requirements.


Information Blocking Rule: Promoting Data Sharing

Implemented in 2021 by the Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ONC), this rule prohibits practices that obstruct patient data sharing. It fosters interoperability while maintaining data security.


Interoperability and Patient Access Rule: Empowering Patients

Enforced by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2021, this rule advocates for patient access to and exchange of electronic health data, thus enhancing patient control over their health information.


Building a Data Privacy and Compliance Framework


Understanding the Laws and Building a Compliance Matrix

To begin, healthcare practices need to understand the scope and requirements of each law. This includes federal laws like HIPAA and the HITECH Act, international regulations such as GDPR, state-specific laws like CCPA, and emerging state laws in Virginia, Colorado, Connecticut, Utah, and more. Creating a compliance matrix that maps out each law’s requirements can help in identifying overlapping areas and specific needs.


Risk Assessment and Gap Analysis

Regular risk assessments and gap analyses are essential. Practices should evaluate where and how patient data is stored, processed, and transmitted. Identifying vulnerabilities and gaps in existing privacy measures against the compliance matrix is crucial for tailoring the privacy framework to the specific needs of the practice.


Tailoring Policies and Procedures

Developing and updating policies and procedures is a foundational step. These should cover data handling, breach notification, patient rights regarding their data, and consent management, particularly under GDPR. Regularly reviewing these policies ensures that they stay current with legislative changes.


Staff Training and Awareness

Continuous staff training and awareness programs are vital. Employees should be educated about the importance of data privacy, the specifics of relevant laws, and the practice’s own privacy policies. Regular training ensures that staff members are aware of their roles in maintaining data privacy.


Implementing Strong Data Security Measures

Adopting robust security measures such as encryption, secure access controls, and regular security audits is a must. These measures should align with HIPAA’s security rule and other relevant standards. Ensuring secure electronic health record (EHR) systems, especially under HITECH, is crucial for protecting electronic health information.


Data Processing and Consent Management

Particularly for GDPR compliance, practices must have clear processes for obtaining and managing patient consent for data processing. This includes transparent information about data usage and easy-to-execute options for patients to withdraw consent.


Patient Data Access and Interoperability

Aligning with the Information Blocking Rule and the Interoperability and Patient Access Rule requires ensuring patients have easy access to their health data and facilitating data exchange in secure and standardised formats.


Establishing a Response Plan for Data Breaches

A well-defined incident response plan for potential data breaches is critical. This plan should include steps for internal reporting, investigation, breach notification (in compliance with HIPAA and other relevant laws), and remediation measures.


Regular Compliance Audits

Conducting regular compliance audits helps in identifying non-compliance areas and implementing corrective actions. These audits can be internal or involve third-party assessors, like those for HITRUST certification.


Engaging Data Privacy Experts

Considering the complexity of data privacy laws, healthcare practices may benefit from consulting with data privacy experts. These professionals can provide guidance on law-specific requirements, risk management strategies, and best practices for data privacy.



Implementing a comprehensive data privacy framework in healthcare is an ongoing process requiring vigilance, adaptability, and a deep understanding of various regulations. By integrating these principles and laws into their operations, healthcare practices can not only comply with legal requirements but also fortify patient trust and ensure the highest standards of data protection.